A personalized children's book review is nothing like a review for a kitchen gadget. No one gives five stars because the pages "flip quickly." When parents review a children's book, they're really sharing about their child—their face lighting up, the line from the story that's become a family joke.
That's why authentic reviews are so valuable for your book. And why they're not easy to get. Most parents are busier than they'd like to be. Here’s how Mr Tales authors ask for reviews in a way that actually works.
:::side /images/brand/img_8720.jpg | A real story, not just stars | When a parent writes a note about your book, it’s rarely in a five-star format. It’s a memory, a quote from a conversation, a small story. These reviews are worth far more than a simple rating.
<h2>Ask at the right moment</h2>
The biggest mistake most authors make is asking for a review right after purchase—or even before. At that point, the parent has nothing to say yet.
The right time is two to three weeks after the book arrives. By then, it’s been read aloud several times. The child has picked a favorite page. The parent knows the story. That’s when the best words come out.
<h2>Don’t just ask for a review—ask for their story</h2>
If you ask for a review, you’ll often get something generic: “Nice book, my child liked it.” That doesn’t help anyone. Instead, ask about their experience.
For example: “What was it like when your child saw the book for the first time?” That gets you responses like: “She opened the package, saw her name on the cover, and said, ‘Mom, that’s me!’” Now that’s a review that speaks to other parents.
<h2>Keep it simple and specific</h2>
Parents are more likely to answer a few direct questions than to fill out a blank box. Don’t send an open-ended request. Send a few specific, easy questions that can each be answered in a sentence or two: <ul><ul><li>What’s your child’s favorite page?</li><li>Which line does your child repeat most?</li><li>When do you usually read the book together?</li></ul></ul> Three quick answers give a clearer picture than a long paragraph—and parents won’t get overwhelmed.
:::stat 3 | The number of short questions parents are willing to answer in under five minutes. They’ll rarely fill out a blank field.
<h2>Respect privacy first</h2>
Always ask permission before sharing a parent’s words anywhere, especially if their child’s name is included. Many parents are happy to have their review featured on your website or social media, but don’t want their child to be easily identified.
A helpful tip: ask if you can use their review with just a first name and city, or just an initial. Give them the choice. This lowers the barrier and usually gets more yeses.
<h2>Photos are gold</h2>
A review with a photo of a child holding the book is far more powerful than one without. But don’t directly ask for a photo—it can feel awkward. Instead, ask if they’d like to share a photo “just for you to enjoy.” Many parents will spontaneously send a picture with their child. Then, ask if you can use that photo alongside their review.
<h2>What to do with negative reviews</h2>
They’ll happen. Maybe a child didn’t love the book, or a parent didn’t like the illustrations, or shipping took longer than expected. Don’t ignore these. Thank the parent for their honesty, offer to make things right if you can, and don’t hide the review.
A few negative reviews among the positives make the whole collection more believable. Almost no one trusts a product with only five-star ratings.
:::quote Debbie S., author of a book about her dog | I think I had my book of true stories about me and my dog on my doorstep within two weeks. So happy with their concept and the wonderful support.
<h2>Make it a habit</h2>
Collecting reviews isn’t a one-time thing—it’s a habit. Set up a routine: send a friendly message three weeks after shipping, with a few specific questions. If you do this consistently, you’ll have a great collection of reviews by the end of the year.
:::cta Ready to collect reviews for your book? | Start your publication in the Mr Tales Creator Tool and build a community of readers eager to share their stories. | /en/become-author | Start your book
Read also: <a href="/en/blog/find-your-first-100-readers-without-a-marketing-budget">How to find your first 100 readers without a marketing budget</a>.